Homeowner guide
Tankless vs Tank Water Heater: A Side-by-Side Comparison
Short answer
A tank water heater stores heated water and is simpler and usually cheaper to install, but it can run out and loses heat while it sits. A tankless heater heats water on demand, does not run out at its rated flow, saves space and typically lasts longer, but may need gas, venting or electrical upgrades.
The better choice depends on your household's hot water use, fuel type, space and existing utilities.
How do tank and tankless water heaters work?
A tank (storage) water heater keeps a tank of water, commonly 30 to 80 gallons in homes, heated and ready. When you use hot water, cold water enters the bottom and the burner or elements reheat it. Because the tank stays hot around the clock, it loses some heat through its walls, called standby loss.
A tankless (on-demand) water heater has no storage tank. When a hot tap opens, water flows through a heat exchanger and a gas burner or electric element heats it instantly. When the tap closes, it shuts off. There is no standby loss from a tank.
Tankless vs tank: side-by-side comparison
| Factor | Tank water heater | Tankless water heater |
|---|---|---|
| Hot water supply | Limited to tank capacity; can run out, then must recover | Continuous at its rated flow rate; can be limited if many fixtures run at once |
| Typical lifespan (commonly cited) | About 8 to 12 years | Often around 20 years with maintenance |
| Energy efficiency | Lower, due to standby heat loss | Higher for most homes; DOE estimates 24 to 34 percent more efficient for homes using 41 gallons or less per day |
| Space | Large footprint, usually a closet, garage or basement | Wall-mounted, compact; some models install outdoors in mild climates |
| Upfront installation | Simpler, especially when replacing like for like | More complex; may need larger gas line, new venting or heavy electrical service |
| Maintenance | Flush sediment, check anode rod | Descale heat exchanger, clean inlet filter |
| Power outage | Gas tanks with standing pilots may still heat; most others need power | Needs electricity for controls and fan, even on gas |
| Hot water delay | Water already hot at the tank | Short delay while unit fires; cold water sandwich possible |
| Hard water sensitivity | Sediment buildup in tank | Scale in heat exchanger can cause errors and reduce life |
The DOE's Energy Saver guidance also estimates tankless heaters can be 8 to 14 percent more efficient for homes using a lot of hot water, around 86 gallons per day.
Which is better for a large family?
A tankless heater never runs out at its rated flow, but its flow rate, measured in gallons per minute (GPM), limits how many fixtures can run at once. In cold climates, incoming water is colder, so the same unit delivers fewer GPM at a comfortable temperature. Large households sometimes need a high-capacity unit or two units installed together.
A tank heater is sized by its first-hour rating, the amount of hot water it can deliver in an hour starting full. A big household with back-to-back showers may need a large tank, or may simply run out at peak times.
A plumber can size either type based on your fixtures, household size and groundwater temperature.
Gas, electric or heat pump?
- Gas tankless: high output, popular for whole-house use. Usually needs a properly sized gas line and dedicated venting. See gas line installation.
- Electric tankless: no venting, but whole-house models draw a lot of power and may need an electrical service upgrade. Often a good fit for point-of-use or smaller loads.
- Gas tank: familiar and simple to replace like for like.
- Electric tank: no venting or gas line needed.
- Heat pump (hybrid) tank: very efficient electric option that moves heat from surrounding air; needs space and airflow and works best in warmer spaces.
If you ever smell gas near a water heater, leave the home and call your gas utility or 911 from outside.
What installation changes does switching to tankless require?
- Gas line upsizing, since tankless gas units can draw much more gas at full fire than a tank burner
- New venting, often PVC for condensing models, or stainless for non-condensing
- A condensate drain for condensing units
- An electrical outlet for controls, or a large dedicated circuit for electric models
- Isolation valves to allow descaling
- A permit and inspection in most areas
These factors are why a like-for-like tank replacement is usually the simpler job. See tankless water heaters and water heater installation.
How does maintenance compare?
Tank heaters need periodic flushing to remove sediment, a check of the anode rod every few years and testing of the relief valve. Tankless heaters need periodic descaling (flushing the heat exchanger with a descaling solution), cleaning of the inlet water filter and occasional service of burners and sensors. In hard water areas, a water softener or scale-control system can protect either type. See hard water and plumbing.
Which should I choose?
| If this describes you | Often a good fit |
|---|---|
| Want simple, like-for-like replacement with minimal changes | Tank |
| Short on space | Tankless |
| Frequently run out of hot water | Tankless (properly sized) or larger tank |
| Plan to stay in the home a long time | Tankless or heat pump |
| Very hard water and no plan to treat it | Tank, or tankless with softening |
| Want to reduce energy use on electric | Heat pump water heater |
To see how long your current unit may last, read water heater lifespan.
What size tankless water heater do I need?
Tankless units are sized by two numbers: flow rate in gallons per minute and the temperature rise needed. Temperature rise is the difference between the incoming cold water and the hot water you want, often around 120 degrees F at the tap.
- Add up the flow rates of fixtures you might run at once, such as two showers and a kitchen faucet.
- Estimate your incoming water temperature. Groundwater is much colder in northern states than in southern states, especially in winter.
- Pick a unit that delivers the needed GPM at your temperature rise, using the maker's chart.
The DOE notes that a gas tankless unit typically produces a higher flow rate than an electric one. An undersized tankless unit is the most common cause of complaints, so sizing is worth getting right.
Frequently asked questions
Do tankless water heaters really never run out?
They provide continuous hot water up to their rated flow rate. If demand exceeds that rate, water temperature drops.
Is tankless more energy efficient?
For most homes, yes, because there is no standby loss. The DOE estimates 24 to 34 percent better efficiency for homes using 41 gallons or less of hot water per day.
Can I install a tankless water heater myself?
It is not a typical DIY job. Gas sizing, venting, electrical and permit requirements make a licensed plumber the right choice.
Do tankless water heaters work during a power outage?
Most do not, even gas models, because they need electricity for controls and fans.
Can I add a tankless unit and keep my tank?
Some homes use a small point-of-use tankless unit for a far bathroom or a kitchen, alongside a main tank. A plumber can tell you if it fits your setup.
Related services
Need a plumber?
Drains, leaks, water heaters, sewer lines and emergencies, day or night.
Call (855) 902-0055